Overall, The Avett Brothers delivers exactly what fans crave—more Avetts. As I mentioned in the beginning, I personally miss the rowdy yellin’, out-of-tune banjo clanging, and the overall rough aesthetic that initially brought them to prominence. That said, I can never be mad at the Avetts. They were among the first to bring roots music to the mainstream masses without the help of big radio. With 11 albums under their belt, it’s inevitable that their sound would grow and evolve. When paired with Rick Rubin, the brothers have unmistakably developed a distinct sound.

Sometimes I wonder if the fault lies with me—perhaps they’re not making music for “me.” I often see hundreds of comments just like, “You guys have been an inspiration for emotional and spiritual growth in my life and therapy for the suffering of existence,” or “I think the world could use some new Avett Brothers songs right about now,” or “They make me cry, but they also make me hopeful and happy.”

All in all, no matter what I, or anyone else thinks about this album, The Avett Brothers continue to do what they do best: touch people and heal them in profound ways. Somehow, these two brothers have cultivated an audience that thinks of them not only as entertainers, but as family. They are never negative and always spread love and positive vibes. Behind their harmonizing lies a gleam of hope for millions of people. The Avett Brothers is another solid entry in their catalog and a step further towards a deliberate stylistic choice.

Is it for me? Well, I don’t think that really matters…. These guys are roots music GOATs, literally healing the world.